When is Divorce Mediation Not Recommended?

Angry couple arguing during the divorce process

Divorce mediation can be a constructive method for resolving disputes between spouses who are willing to collaborate on reaching an agreement. However, there are specific situations where mediation might not be recommended or effective.

Divorce mediation is often praised for its ability to help separating couples resolve their disputes amicably and cost-effectively. However, while mediation can be a valuable tool for many, there are certain situations where it may not be the best option. Understanding when divorce mediation is not recommended is crucial for ensuring both parties can achieve a fair and safe resolution to their marital dissolution. 

  1. Domestic Violence: If there is a history of domestic abuse (physical, emotional, or psychological) between the spouses, mediation may not be safe or appropriate. The power imbalance created by abuse can prevent the victim from advocating effectively for their own interests.

  2. Non-Disclosure of Assets: Mediation relies on transparency and honesty. If one party is suspected of hiding assets, being dishonest about their financial situation, or engaging in financial manipulation, mediation may not be effective, as it requires accurate and complete information to negotiate fairly.

  3. Substance Abuse: If one party has severe issues with substance abuse that impair their judgment or ability to participate meaningfully, mediation may not be successful. This issue could lead to unproductive sessions or unfair decision-making.

  4. Unwillingness to Compromise: Mediation requires both parties to be open to negotiation and compromise. If one party is completely inflexible or unwilling to consider the other party’s needs and positions, mediation is likely to be a futile effort.

  5. Mental Health Issues: Significant untreated mental health issues that affect one party’s capacity to make decisions or participate in the mediation process can also make mediation inappropriate.

  6. High Conflict Situations: In cases where there is extreme hostility or an inability to communicate without conflict, the presence of a mediator might not be enough to allow productive and peaceful negotiation.

  7. Legal Complexities: Some divorces involve complex legal issues that require formal legal proceedings to resolve, such as disputes involving international law, complex corporate structures, or significant financial disputes where expert testimony might be necessary.

In such cases, it may be necessary to proceed directly to court or to involve individual legal representation to ensure that the interests of both parties (and any children involved) are adequately protected.

When Divorce Mediation is Not Recommended

In summary, while divorce mediation can offer a less adversarial and more cost-effective alternative to traditional divorce proceedings, it is not suitable for all situations. When divorce mediation is not recommended, typically due to issues like domestic violence, non-disclosure of assets, substance abuse, mental health issues, extreme conflict, unwillingness to compromise, or legal complexities, it is important to seek other legal avenues. If you’re unsure whether mediation is the right path for your situation, Mediator Michaele Gantz can provide invaluable guidance. Contact Michaele to learn more about if mediation is the right path for you. If it’s not, she offers Divorce Coaching, which offers additional support through a difficult divorce with an attorney. 

Michaele is dedicated to providing compassionate and comprehensive support surrounding divorce mediation and related issues. She ensures that all parties are adequately protected and that the outcomes of the divorce proceedings are just and equitable for everyone involved.


Signup our newsletter to get update information, news, insight or promotions.

Latest Articles

Meet Divorce Mediator Michaele Gantz

"Mediation Services for Couples, Families, and Businesses in the New York City Metropolitan Area"